No, all that’s fine as long as you clearly state that you’re not implying that being Jewish makes you a bad person or partially responsible for genocide.
Because that’s what it sounds like you’re implying. And if it is, then that is a logically and morally wrong thing to imply.
The problem is that people aren’t allowed to address the overwhelming support for Israel amongst the Jewish community as if that’s “hating all Jews”.
It’s a thing that needs to be addressed and fixed. Synagogues are selling stolen Palestinian houses and people are being called antisemitic for protesting outside of those Synagogues because “that’s antisemitic”.
The problem is that people aren’t allowed to address the overwhelming support for Israel amongst the Jewish community as if that’s “hating all Jews”.
Of course we are. We can say “there is too much support for Zionism among the Jewish community.” As you say, this is a matter of numbers, and anti-zionist Jews will agree.
But that’s very different from saying “Jews support genocide.” That’s conflating all Jews, ignoring the strong anti-zionist Jewish voices, and opening the doors to our opponents to call us antisemitic.
No, all that’s fine as long as you clearly state that you’re not implying that being Jewish makes you a bad person or partially responsible for genocide.
Because that’s what it sounds like you’re implying. And if it is, then that is a logically and morally wrong thing to imply.
The problem is that people aren’t allowed to address the overwhelming support for Israel amongst the Jewish community as if that’s “hating all Jews”.
It’s a thing that needs to be addressed and fixed. Synagogues are selling stolen Palestinian houses and people are being called antisemitic for protesting outside of those Synagogues because “that’s antisemitic”.
Of course we are. We can say “there is too much support for Zionism among the Jewish community.” As you say, this is a matter of numbers, and anti-zionist Jews will agree.
But that’s very different from saying “Jews support genocide.” That’s conflating all Jews, ignoring the strong anti-zionist Jewish voices, and opening the doors to our opponents to call us antisemitic.