• 0 Posts
  • 8 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 29th, 2024

help-circle







  • Stephenie Meyer.

    Hear me out. Were the books well written? No. Did they describe very toxic and harmful relationship dynamics? Yes. Did they contain weird morals? Also yes.

    These are all things that can be justly criticised. And there is probably a lot more to criticise. But did Stephanie Meyer, and to some extent her readers, really deserve the huge wave of hate they got? Were the books really objectively worse than other YA fiction? Or was it just because they were popular among young women?

    I was a teenager when the books came out and loved them. (Though even then I did not understand why they needed to marry so young and she lost me with the whole Renesmee thing). Now I cringe hard about almost any aspect of them, but hate is going a bit overboard.

    And at least Meyer (to my knowledge) didn’t try to push her weird worldviews onto us outside of her book, unlike JKR.