- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
- cross-posted to:
- [email protected]
- [email protected]
It’s a good thing Europa has moved past all that fractious border shenanigans

Well, countries are all more or less delusions, yet made more or less real by the authority of states.
The real delusion in this story is that German is a language. From what I’ve heard, take three Germans from different regions, all speaking their mother tongue and they’ll have just as much trouble understanding each other as three Spaniards from diverse parts of Spain†. But while the Spaniards will be well aware that one of them is speaking Galician, one Castellan and another Catalonian, each German is convinced that he’s speaking German and that the others are speaking German in a weird way. Spaniards will likely speak Castellan, if not as their first then as their second language. Germans will all be familiar with a standard German but not really identify it as a distinct language from their own. Same story in Italy.
†: Assuming none of the Spaniards in the example are Basque.
The real delusion in this story is that German is a language.
Now let’s talk about Dutch.
germany has about 4-5 truly difficult dialects I’d say. (being an native speaker) I could understand every dialect after being immersed for a couple of hours except for bavarian tho 😅
there are a lot more local accents and dialects but Sächsisch, Pfälzerisch & Bayrisch are the ones that are really difficult to understand even for german natives from other areas. Hessisch partially as well. These are all bound to their local areas.
I’m speaking Hochdeutsch (“plain german” which should be the german y’all are learning in school) but there is also Plattdeutsch (spoken mostly in the north) which is it’s own language that is on it’s way to extinction.
ich bin mir auch ziemlich sicher, dass du kein platt oder allemannisch (aka “schweizerisch”) verstehst. Und ich behaupte mal, heute haben wir sehr viel weniger deutsche dialekte als noch vor 200 jahren.
& er hat noch nie nen Schwaben getroffen? Wenn er mit Hessisch schon Probleme hat?
hochdeutsch actually refers to the “higher altitude” dialects from the south like bavarian, saxon or swabian…
you actually mean standarddeutsch
No idea, if that’s a regional thing that “Hochdeutsch” primarily means Southern German to you, but here in South Germany, I doubt anyone would be aware of your definition and everyone understands “Hochdeutsch” to mean “Standard High German”.
My dictionary does list the Southern German meaning, but it’s listed as the secondary meaning.
Explanation: In the Medieval and Early Modern period, the area we now know as Germany was home to a… staggering variety of independent polities.
… it would take quite some time for them all to be sorted out and put under one flag.
Why didn’t Bohemia, the largest polity, not simply eat the other polities?
We ate Moravia, the second largest, so there’s that.
too busying creating the RHAPSODY?
The smaller polities can ally.
Also, a single small polity can be relatively powerful based on its wealth and population density. It can also have local defensive advantages.
Fighting the French did help a lot
Hatred of the French brings people together.
The enemy of my enemy is my friend.
The enemy of my enemy is the French. Even if my enemy is the French, then the enemy of them is probably Parisians.
That makes Parisians your friends. They have the SAME goal as you. They can HELP you.
Nah, despite the rest, Parisians are the worst.
Acshually briefly being governed by a certain french gentleman helped a lot more.
You’re right. Bonaparte is the common factor of every European country’s journey to unification, except the UK of course
Fun fact: Germany was founded in Versailles: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Proclamation_of_the_German_Empire_(paintings)
Interacting with France is the gateway drug to country-hood.
Nothing quite like the mutual desire to not be french for making friends.
Maybe people of the future will watch our Europe chart and wonder how United Europe ever managed to unite.
“Unification” = Prussian dominance through conquering, alliances, and coercion.
I find the standard historical descriptor “unification” to be statist embellishing and give the false idea that this was somehow grassroots.
I find the standard historical descriptor “unification” to be statist embellishing and give the false idea that this was somehow grassroots.
“War is politics through other means”, and all that jazz. German unification movements were widespread and a key component of Prussia’s success was leveraging that grassroots enthusiasm towards a unified German nation to assist them, by portraying themselves as the most likely to be able to achieve it.
Napoleon. Yes, it’s a little oversimplified but that man really shaped Europe and Germany with it.
Napoleon the third to be specific. Bismarck helped. A little bit.
"France, under Emperor Napoleon III, viewed Prussia’s growing power with suspicion and sought to curb its influence.
The immediate catalyst for the Franco-Prussian War was the Ems Dispatch, a diplomatic communication edited by Bismarck to provoke French ire. The altered message made it seem as though the Prussian King Wilhelm I had insulted the French ambassador, leading to public outrage in France and a declaration of war on July 19, 1870."
"The Franco-Prussian War had profound consequences for both France and Germany, as well as for the broader European political landscape.
The most significant outcome of the war was the unification of Germany. On January 18, 1871, in the Hall of Mirrors at the Palace of Versailles, King Wilhelm I of Prussia was proclaimed Emperor of the German Empire. This unification shifted the balance of power in Europe, establishing Germany as a major continental power."
That’s not what OP meant. Napoleon I occupied the German states and brought a lot of reforms including the abolition of feudalism, legal reforms, and administrative efficiency including centralized state governments. He completely reshaped German state borders. As an example, this article (in German) explains how 250 independent territories were merged into 3 territories (which nowadays are one state).
Which ironically kinda makes him a founding father in a weird way.
France already knows that Germany likes to take French rulers and claim them as founders of Germany. See: Charlemagne.
It’s a two month old comment, but I’m here from a cross-post (piefed just shows the comments under the other posts), but:
-
It’s Karl der Große
-
When the Pope had (once again) trouble in Rome, he fled to Karl in Paderborn, a German city.
-
He regarded Aachen, another German city, as the second Rome and was his main residence.
-
He was buried in Aachen.
-
Franks were a Germanic tribe who took a slice of the Roman empire. We are just having cousins disputes.
###Electorate of Cologne represent!

(*throws another archbishop to the curb*)
Großherzogtum Baden FTW

I‘m gonna take a bath in Baden-Baden now.







