I mean, personally I agree the magic system is lazy and the world is nonsensical, but “good” is more subjective than that. I disliked the books and never even finished the series, it tool YEARS before I even read 5&6, and I don’t think I’ve seen past the 3rd movie. Except meme clips anyway.
But if someone else wants to lament how something they liked is tied to a bigot, let them lament in peace.
Yeah, I too personally never really cared for them. Like, they were OK, I read the first 3 books and yeah, it was a story but I never really got into this “world of wonder and whimsy” stuff. I read the rest of the books as they got released just to finish the story and I don’t think I saw any in the cinema.
But that was me, one of my closer friends at school though was utterly obsessed. They purchased all the merchandise, watched all the films in the cinema, multiple times, read all the fanfiction (and the naughty fanfiction…), played the games etc. etc.
So yeah, I agree that for me I, never really cared about it, it meant nothing more to me than any one of the number of kids books I read. But for others it did form so much of their childhood, it was important. From writing their own fanfiction to drawing art or programming games, I’m sure a lot of people have had it influence their adult life really heavily and, especially those who don’t quite understand the level of harm she is doing and maybe don’t even know anyone personally who is being harmed, this could seem like a real attack on their childhood, we should be able to recognise that and treat that with compassion rather than say the books are crap and you are an evil person for still liking them, which will only serve to harden them.
You’re allowed to like horrible things made by horrible people! There’s a rice dish my mom used to make that’s kind of my not-quite-comfort food. I just wouldn’t recommend it. Its trash. And when I make it, I don’t even burn it every time.
Harry Potter is trash. It’s not the worst thing ever, but it’s not worth your time. Anyone’s time, really.
I’m not defending Harry Potter, I don’t even like it myself, but Christ that first sentence rubs me the wrong way. Maybe things can be subjective and not every art piece is just “good” or “bad” in the end. There’s no reason to be so passive aggressive and belittling in your response here.
Its morally horrible technically uninteresting creatively uninspired. Sorry, I’ll be more nuanced in my broad thesis statements rather than the main body of my comments. I forget sometimes people only read headlines.
No like… There’s subjective stuff about what food is good. Is the best food curry? A perfectly grown raw strawberry? Caesar salad? Expresso gelato? Engineered hypernutritious silicon valley bodybuilder slop? but like… Harry Potter is a gas station burrito with some popcorn ceiling sprinkled on top, rolled in the author’s opinions.
I mean, personally I agree the magic system is lazy and the world is nonsensical, but “good” is more subjective than that. I disliked the books and never even finished the series, it tool YEARS before I even read 5&6, and I don’t think I’ve seen past the 3rd movie. Except meme clips anyway.
But if someone else wants to lament how something they liked is tied to a bigot, let them lament in peace.
Yeah, I too personally never really cared for them. Like, they were OK, I read the first 3 books and yeah, it was a story but I never really got into this “world of wonder and whimsy” stuff. I read the rest of the books as they got released just to finish the story and I don’t think I saw any in the cinema.
But that was me, one of my closer friends at school though was utterly obsessed. They purchased all the merchandise, watched all the films in the cinema, multiple times, read all the fanfiction (and the naughty fanfiction…), played the games etc. etc.
So yeah, I agree that for me I, never really cared about it, it meant nothing more to me than any one of the number of kids books I read. But for others it did form so much of their childhood, it was important. From writing their own fanfiction to drawing art or programming games, I’m sure a lot of people have had it influence their adult life really heavily and, especially those who don’t quite understand the level of harm she is doing and maybe don’t even know anyone personally who is being harmed, this could seem like a real attack on their childhood, we should be able to recognise that and treat that with compassion rather than say the books are crap and you are an evil person for still liking them, which will only serve to harden them.
You’re allowed to like horrible things made by horrible people! There’s a rice dish my mom used to make that’s kind of my not-quite-comfort food. I just wouldn’t recommend it. Its trash. And when I make it, I don’t even burn it every time.
Harry Potter is trash. It’s not the worst thing ever, but it’s not worth your time. Anyone’s time, really.
I’m not defending Harry Potter, I don’t even like it myself, but Christ that first sentence rubs me the wrong way. Maybe things can be subjective and not every art piece is just “good” or “bad” in the end. There’s no reason to be so passive aggressive and belittling in your response here.
Its morally horrible technically uninteresting creatively uninspired. Sorry, I’ll be more nuanced in my broad thesis statements rather than the main body of my comments. I forget sometimes people only read headlines.
I read the rest of your comment, you know. The work you’re talking about arguably being shit doesn’t mean you have to be so passive aggressive.
I don’t think I’m being passive. I think I’m being sarcastic and bitter about mother fuckers reading selectively to avoid being communicated with.
No like… There’s subjective stuff about what food is good. Is the best food curry? A perfectly grown raw strawberry? Caesar salad? Expresso gelato? Engineered hypernutritious silicon valley bodybuilder slop? but like… Harry Potter is a gas station burrito with some popcorn ceiling sprinkled on top, rolled in the author’s opinions.
Ah, the heaviest artillery of art criticism: food comparisons.
You can’t exactly call it art except in the broadest sense that choosing to splatter shit over one part of the toilet bowl instead of another is art.